MPI Forum meeting: Votes and Formal Readings from the meeting

Prior Meeting

See the prior meeting formal readings / votes to know what will be coming up for this meeting.

Formal Readings:

1. There were no formal readings at this meeting.

Votes:

NOTE: "Missed" counts the same as "abstain".

1. Vote topic: Ticket #187: "Grouping MPI_AINT, MPI_OFFSET, MPI_COUNT as Multi-language types ", 1st vote

   YES:	15
   NO:	0
   ABSTAIN:	1
   MISSED:	0
   Result:	Ballot passed

   
   
2. Vote topic: Ticket #192: "C++ binding for Dist_graph_neighbors_count is badly broken ", 1st vote

   YES:	14
   NO:	1
   ABSTAIN:	1
   MISSED:	0
   Result:	Ballot passed

   
   
3. Vote topic: Ticket #195: "Topology awareness in MPI_Dims_create ", 1st vote

   YES:	2
   NO:	10
   ABSTAIN:	4
   MISSED:	0
   Result:	Ballot failed

   
   
4. Vote topic: Ticket #217: "MPI3 Hybrid Programming: Proposal for Helper Threads ", 1st vote

   YES:	7
   NO:	8
   ABSTAIN:	1
   MISSED:	0
   Result:	Ballot failed

   
   
5. Vote topic: Ticket #256: "MPI_PROC_NULL behavior for MPI_PROBE and MPI_IPROBE not directly defined ", 1st vote

   YES:	15
   NO:	0
   ABSTAIN:	1
   MISSED:	0
   Result:	Ballot passed

   
   
6. Vote topic: Ticket #271: "Functions to query MPI_Info object attached to windows and communicators ", 1st vote

   YES:	14
   NO:	1
   ABSTAIN:	1
   MISSED:	0
   Result:	Ballot passed

   
   
7. Vote topic: Ticket #273: "Add Immediate versions of nonblocking collective I/O routines ", 1st vote

   YES:	8
   NO:	2
   ABSTAIN:	6
   MISSED:	0
   Result:	Ballot failed

   
   
8. Vote topic: Ticket #278: "Update examples to not use deprecated constructs (where possible) ", 1st vote

   YES:	10
   NO:	0
   ABSTAIN:	6
   MISSED:	0
   Result:	Ballot passed

   
   
9. Vote topic: Ticket #281: "Remove C++ Bindings ", 1st vote

   YES:	11
   NO:	5
   ABSTAIN:	0
   MISSED:	0
   Result:	Ballot passed

   
   
10. Vote topic: Ticket #294: "MPI_UNWEIGHTED should not be NULL ", 1st vote

    YES:	16
    NO:	0
    ABSTAIN:	0
    MISSED:	0
    Result:	Ballot passed

    
    
11. Vote topic: Ticket #300: "Fix issue with definition of nonblocking in One Sided Chapter ", 1st vote

    YES:	14
    NO:	0
    ABSTAIN:	2
    MISSED:	0
    Result:	Ballot passed

    
    
12. Vote topic: Ticket #303: "Move MPI-1 deprecated functions to new "Removed Interfaces" chapter ", 1st vote

    YES:	9
    NO:	5
    ABSTAIN:	2
    MISSED:	0
    Result:	Ballot passed

    
    
13. Vote topic: Ticket #313: "MPI_INIT & MPI_FINALIZE ", 1st vote

    YES:	11
    NO:	1
    ABSTAIN:	4
    MISSED:	0
    Result:	Ballot passed

    
    
14. Vote topic: Ticket #310: "clarify MPI behavior when multiple MPI processes run in the same address space ", 1st vote

    YES:	3
    NO:	7
    ABSTAIN:	6
    MISSED:	0
    Result:	Ballot failed

    
    
15. Vote topic: Ticket #317: "correct error related to MPI_REQUEST_FREE ", 1st vote

    YES:	15
    NO:	0
    ABSTAIN:	1
    MISSED:	0
    Result:	Ballot passed

    
    
16. Vote topic: Ticket #323: "User-Level Failure Mitigation ", 1st vote

    YES:	7
    NO:	5
    ABSTAIN:	4
    MISSED:	0
    Result:	Ballot failed

    
    
17. Vote topic: Ticket #328: "fix MPI_PROC_NULL behavior for mprobe/improbe/mrecv/imrecv ", 1st vote

    YES:	16
    NO:	0
    ABSTAIN:	0
    MISSED:	0
    Result:	Ballot passed

    
    
18. Vote topic: Ticket #308: "RMA - Remove sentence on offset in datatypes ", 2nd vote

    YES:	16
    NO:	0
    ABSTAIN:	0
    MISSED:	0
    Result:	Ballot passed

    
    
19. Vote topic: Ticket #309: "RMA - Clarify usage of status for request-based RMA operations ", 2nd vote

    YES:	16
    NO:	0
    ABSTAIN:	0
    MISSED:	0
    Result:	Ballot passed

    
    
20. Vote topic: Ticket #284: "Allocate a shared memory window ", 2nd vote

    YES:	13
    NO:	0
    ABSTAIN:	3
    MISSED:	0
    Result:	Ballot passed

    
    
21. Vote topic: Ticket #280: "Add a new datatype creation routine - MPI_Type_create_hindexed_block ", 2nd vote

    YES:	16
    NO:	0
    ABSTAIN:	0
    MISSED:	0
    Result:	Ballot passed

    
    
22. Vote topic: Ticket #168: "Nonblocking Communicator Duplication ", 2nd vote

    YES:	13
    NO:	1
    ABSTAIN:	2
    MISSED:	0
    Result:	Ballot passed

    
    
23. Vote topic: Ticket #272: "Remove non-blocking collective C++ bindings ", 2nd vote

    YES:	13
    NO:	1
    ABSTAIN:	2
    MISSED:	0
    Result:	Ballot passed

    
    
24. Vote topic: Ticket #286: "Noncollective Communicator Creation ", 2nd vote

    YES:	15
    NO:	0
    ABSTAIN:	1
    MISSED:	0
    Result:	Ballot passed

    
    
25. Vote topic: Ticket #305: "Update MPI_Intercomm_create to use collective tag space ", 2nd vote

    YES:	14
    NO:	1
    ABSTAIN:	1
    MISSED:	0
    Result:	Ballot passed